June 1, 2012

Cover Story

Educating for the Future

LEARNING THAT WORKS Enhancing Utah’s Educational System Ed...Read More

Featured Articles

Around Utah

Scott Beck: Building Relationships and Driving Growth

Sections

People
Pamela Okumura: Helping Utah Businesses Grow

Players
Players

Features
CFO of the Year

Features
Connect the Education Dots

Editor's Note
Making Education a Top Priority


Making Choices

Focus
Dreaming of a White Winter

Legal Briefs
Consider Mediation

Money Talk
Unconventional Wisdom

Economic Insight
Guiding Principles

Lessons Learned
Armed and Dangerous

TechKnowledge
Chain Reaction

EntrepreneurEdge
Like to Enter

Business Trends
Kill or Cure

Executive Living
Tech for On-the-go Execs

Regional Report
Summit/Wasatch Regional Outlook

Industry Outlook
LEGAL

Article

Unconventional Wisdom

Establishing a Distribution Rate for a Secure Retirement

Brad Thurber is a key financial consultant in the Salt Lake City office of D.A. Davidson & Co.

June 1, 2012


Planning for retirement is probably the single most significant challenge that an investor will face. After spending a career accumulating sufficient assets, individuals are suddenly thrust to the back-end of the process: taking distributions. Retirees face the twin challenges of covering expenses and not depleting savings too quickly. A misstep could mean having insufficient funds to see them through retirement.

Historically, the retirement planning process has comprised of two completely separate phases: accumulation during
the working years and distribution once in retirement. Though financial consultants followed a logical and straight-forward process to determine retirement needs, the traditional process placed an extraordinary amount of pressure on choosing the right withdrawal rate
for distributions.

The 4-Percent Solution
For about the past two decades, financial consultants have hung their hats on a distribution rate of 4 percent. In a study published by William Bengen nearly 20 years ago and using historical data dating back to 1926, this pace was determined as a safe distribution rate for a portfolio divided equally between large cap stocks and bonds in virtually any type of economic environment. More recently, however, the accuracy of this solution has come under increased scrutiny.

To understand the shortfalls of the 4-percent rule, consider two investors on the cusp of retirement in 2008, each with $1 million saved at the beginning of the year. The first investor retires at the beginning of 2008, and using the 4-percent standard, withdraws $40,000 annually throughout her retirement. The second investor postpones retirement until the end of 2008. Over the course of the year, however, his $1 million portfolio takes a hit and declines to $700,000. Applying the 4-percent rule, this investor would receive a distribution of $28,000 per year during retirement.

Despite achieving the same savings goal by early 2008, market conditions and timing made a $12,000 per year difference in retirement incomes. What the 4-percent approach doesn’t consider is market performance during the distribution phase, not just
during accumulation.

An Integrated Approach
A new approach that considers market performance history during both the accumulation and distribution phases can help investors plan better for retirement. A recent study conducted by Wade Pfau, who holds a doctorate in economics from Princeton University, uses data stretching back to 1870 and suggests that evaluating historical simulations that include accumulation and distribution phases can provide a more accurate prediction of a sustainable distribution rate.

As a result of Pfau’s research, financial consultants are doing a couple of things differently. First, consultants are taking the cyclicality of the markets into greater account. Historical data shows that the lowest maximum distribution rates (the most an investor could withdraw safely without running out of money) tend to occur after prolonged bull markets. For investors facing retirement following such market environments, establishing a lower distribution rate may help portfolios withstand potentially challenging markets ahead.

Conversely, prolonged bear markets during the wealth accumulation phase tend to allow for higher maximum withdrawal rates. For those retiring at the end of a challenging period, it may be possible to establish a higher distribution rate in anticipation of stronger markets ahead. For instance, investors retiring at the end of the 1970s could have used a distribution rate exceeding 6 percent over 30 years without running out of money. Of course, these bull and bear market relationships are not perfectly predictable.

Along with market cyclicality, consultants are also revisiting at which rate investors are saving for retirement. It is still critical to begin the planning process with an estimate of the withdrawals needed from a pool of assets to cover expenses. Now, however, the second step is to focus on establishing a sufficient savings rate.

By focusing on the savings rate, investors are concentrating on a planning element they can control. Plus, with consistent savings over time, there may be less reliance on market performance during the final years of accumulation. According to Phau’s data, an investor planning to work for 30 years and desiring to replace 50 percent of her working income from retirement assets should be successful in nearly any economic environment by dedicating 16.62 percent of her income annually to retirement savings.

Giving Investors More Control
Clearly, many other variables and assumptions factor into a retirement plan, including life expectancy, asset allocation, inflation, etc. It’s certainly not an exact science. However, by integrating market return assumptions during both the accumulation and distribution phases of an investor’s life, it is possible to determine more accurately what investors can control—the amount of money to save now to ensure obligations are met during retirement.

Utah Business Social
UB Events View All
Health Care HeroesUtah Business Event
Oct 21, 2014
Please join us, along with our sponsors, MountainStar Healthcare, and Roseman University in honor...
Content Marketing BootcampUtah Business Event
Oct 28, 2014
Please join Utah Business Magazine, along with our sponsor Adobe, for an in-depth, hands-on, educ...
Community Events View All
Utah's Crossroads Conference
Sep 17, 2014
The Crossroads Conference is the largest HR conference in Utah! It offers comprehensive and relev...
Business Succession Planning Seminar
Sep 17, 2014
You've built your legacy. Now don't leave anything to chance. Learn from attorneys and business p...

info@utahbusiness.com  |  90 South 400 West, Ste 650 Salt Lake City, Utah 84101   |  (801) 568-0114

Advertise with Utah Business

Submit an Event

* indicates required information
* Event Name:
Price (general):
Website (if applicable):
Coordinator's Name:
Coordinator's Email:
Coordinator's Phone:
Venue Name:
Venue Address:
Venue City:
Venue Zip:
Event Capacity:
Date(s):
to
* Event Description:
  Cancel