June 1, 2008

Cover Story

Opportunity Knocks

On a warm summer evening, a well-groomed, neatly dressed young man knocks on ...Read More

Featured Articles

Jill Miller

Mick Hagen

Sections

Regional Report
Wasatch and Summit Counties

Industry Outlook
Legal

Focus
Propelling Utah's Economy

Features
The New Media Mix

Features
The R Word

EntrepreneurEdge
From Delta to Dusseldorf

TechKnowledge
Where's Wi-Fi

Legal Briefs
Meet in the Middle

Executive Living
The Total Package

Executive Getaways
Crank It Up

Executive Health
The Home Stretch

Article

Meet in the Middle

Mediation -- Because Who Wants to Go to Court?

Gretta Spendlove

June 1, 2008

“I was never ruined but twice: once when I lost a lawsuit, and once when I won one.” —Voltaire Picture two business partners, Susan and Dale, who have worked together for fifteen years, developing a wholesale business. They find it increasingly hard to work together, and decide to split up. Susan offers to sell Dale her half interest in the business for $1 million. The offer is much higher than Dale thinks is fair. Susan and Dale talk to each other and exchange appraisals, information, and arguments from their attorneys and accountants. Nothing works. What to do? File a suit? Many businesspeople consider being sued one of the low points of their lives. Win or lose, litigation is stressful and expensive. There is, however, an alternative for solving business disputes. Increasingly, mediation is used instead of, or together with, litigation. Mediation is a voluntary process in which disputing parties choose their own mediator, or neutral party, to help them solve their problem. A mediator would help Susan and Dale consider various buy/sell or continue-to-work-together approaches. It is a flexible process, with the parties setting their own timetable and being as creative as they choose in the solutions to their problem. As Steve Gordon, Salt Lake City attorney and mediator points out, mediation can last from two hours to two years. In complex cases, the parties can get one issue of the case solved through mediation and come back later to work on another one. Why Mediate? Some contracts require mediation of disputes. Some judges order parties to mediate before proceeding with the lawsuit, or strongly recommend it. Some parties decide themselves to try solving problems through mediation, either before a lawsuit is filed or while it continues. Mediation can be a more efficient way to solve problems than litigation. As Gordon explains, courts can decide who gets money, but a lot of times what clients really want isn’t just money. They may want vindication or a sincere apology, in addition to money. They may want to tell their story and have the other side really listen. In our hypothetical, Susan and Dale may want a buy-out of their business by one partner or shared ownership by both, remedies a court may not be able to offer. To get started, the parties provide information about their case to a mediator, and then schedule a meeting. The parties spend the mediation meeting together and apart, with the mediator guiding the discussion between them and caucusing separately with each party to explore whether settlement is possible. As Karin Hobbs, Salt Lake City mediator and attorney, points out, mediators run the range from facilitative (the messenger) to analytical (discussing the legal issues) to evaluative (emphasizing the weaknesses to both parties and, if necessary, evaluating the viability of the claims). Most attorneys choosing mediators avoid ones who are “just messengers” and hire “closers,” or mediators who proactively work on both sides to reach a settlement. The mediator may also be skilled in dealing with emotional, recalcitrant or entrenched clients. For instance, the mediator handling the Susan and Dale mediation might have Susan and Dale take a break and walk around the block when the mediation sessions get too stressful. Getting Results The voluntary nature of mediation is what makes it work. Parties should come to the mediation highly motivated to compromise and work their problems out. Flexibility and creativity are really important, too. Gordon remembers one mediation between partners who needed to work together to market a product, but they couldn’t stand each other. Through mediation, they agreed to appoint an “umpire” to solve the ongoing daily fights between them until they could get their product sold. That was a creative solution which a court could not have imposed. Hobbs emphasizes the importance of preparation in mediation, and realizing that resolution of problems involves not just objective factors. She recommends that attorneys provide a mediation statement to the mediator which summarizes legal issues, but which also points out “the rest of the story,” including clients’ underlying interests, goals and objectives. For Susan and Dale reaching a settlement might not be their agreement on the objective value of the business, but the mediator helping them to analyze their goals and create a win/win solution. What about the details? A recent Utah case confirms that mediation settlements may not be valid unless they’re reduced to writing. A written settlement agreement is necessary to preserve the agreements made in mediation. Utah mediators typically charge between $250 and $400 per hour, including both the mediation meetings and time spent in preparation. Regardless, mediation offers warring parties like Dale and Susan a chance to emerge from their disputes whole. Gretta Spendlove is a shareholder with the law firm Durham Jones & Pinegar. She can be reached at gspendlove@djplaw.
Utah Business Social
UB Events View All
Best Companies to Work For 2014Utah Business Event
Dec 11, 2014
Utah Business magazine along with our presenting sponsor- CBIZ, premier sponsor- Diversified Insu...
SAMY Awards 2015Utah Business Event
Jan 23, 2015
Utah Business magazine along with Presenting Sponsor Griffin Hill are pleased to present the 201...
Forty Under 40 - 2015Utah Business Event
Feb 26, 2015
Utah Business Magazine along with Presenting Sponsors: Kirton McConkie, BIG-D Construction and Ma...
Community Events View All
Small Business Saturday - Local Shopping Tour Party Bus
Nov 29, 2014
Join us on tour, for a one of a kind local event and get introduced to local shops and deals. Our...
No Fixed Address Giving Tree
Dec 1, 2014
No Fixed Address Giving Tree | All Month Spread joy this holiday season with the gift of giving...

info@utahbusiness.com  |  90 South 400 West, Ste 650 Salt Lake City, Utah 84101   |  (801) 568-0114

Advertise with Utah Business

Submit an Event

* indicates required information
* Event Name:
Price (general):
Website (if applicable):
Coordinator's Name:
Coordinator's Email:
Coordinator's Phone:
Venue Name:
Venue Address:
Venue City:
Venue Zip:
Event Capacity:
Date(s):
to
* Event Description:
  Cancel