February 26, 2013

Cover Story

CEO of the Year

Utah’s business landscape is rich with professionals who have le...Read More

Featured Articles

Did you go Skiing this winter?

Around Utah


Martin Plaehn

Karen Sendelback

Legal Briefs
Social Media and Employers: Friends or Enemies?

Money Talk
The Case for HSAs

Economic Insight
Time to Show Up

Lessons Learned
Make a Move

In the Lab

Rent to Own

Business Trends
Back from the Dead

Living Well
Artful Inspiration

A Breath of Fresh Air

Worst-Case Scenario

Regional Report
Northern Utah

Measure Up

Industry Outlook
Travel & Tourism



Legal Case Profiles

February 26, 2013

At its heart, the BYU v. Pfizer case was a simple breach of contract dispute. “Unfortunately, this happens with some degree of regularity in America,” says Bettilyon. However, the case also raised important issues about discovery and document retention.

In 2009, mid-way through the dispute, Pfizer was ordered to pay more than $850,000 in fines and attorney fees for discovery delays and document destruction. BYU later filed additional motions for sanctions related to discovery, but the judge ruled that Pfizer appeared to be cooperating and that the company was not required to retain electronic documents dating back to the ‘90s without the reasonable expectation of legal proceedings related to the data.

 The case highlights the importance for companies of implementing a good-faith document retention policy that allows for electronic data to be deleted after a set period of time and when it is clear the data is not pertinent to an impending legal action.

Bettilyon also says Pfizer’s original misconduct and subsequent sanctions highlights the need for attorneys to discuss discovery with their clients early on. “When you are at the beginning stages of litigation, counsel should have a conversation with their client to make sure they understand their obligations in regard to retaining and producing documents,” he says.

With the six-year legal battle now settled, Bettilyon says, “This was a fascinating case because it involved a lot of biotechnology. It was an incredible opportunity for me to learn new things.”

Page 12345
Utah Business Social
UB Events View All
Utah Employers Healthcare Summit and Healthcare Heroes Utah Business Event
Oct 6, 2015
The Utah Employers Healthcare Summit is a gathering of all of the major employers, healthcare pro...
Twenty in Their 20sUtah Business Event
Nov 5, 2015
Meet the young and ambitious professionals who are taking the business world by storm! The honore...
Sustainable Business Awards Utah Business Event
Nov 19, 2015
Utah Business magazine is pleased to announce the Utah Sustainable Business Awards. This program ...
Community Events View All
9th Annual CHINA Town Hall: Chinese Investment in the United States
Oct 5, 2015
CHINA Town Hall is a national day of programming on China involving 70 cities throughout the Unit...
Oct 6, 2015
Link to tickets: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/secrets-to-financing-your-business-tickets-18611033...

info@utahbusiness.com  |  90 South 400 West, Ste 650 Salt Lake City, Utah 84101   |  (801) 568-0114

Advertise with Utah Business

Submit an Event

* indicates required information
* Event Name:
Price (general):
Website (if applicable):
Coordinator's Name:
Coordinator's Email:
Coordinator's Phone:
Venue Name:
Venue Address:
Venue City:
Venue Zip:
Event Capacity:
* Event Description: